10mm Vs 357 For Bear

As Wwf stated the 10mm rounds are more expensive and may be tougher to find depending on locality. Towsley , Tyler Freel , and John B. The fact it has been adopted for use by skymarshals, the Secret Service and Texas Rangers are proof. It can be handloaded to near. The 10mm penetration was around 16 inches. 357 is a huge roll of the dice. at close range with a. The 40sw is a lot shy of a full house 357 mag and a full power 10mm. I found the test guns used for verification is an 8 inch. Paul James did additional research on the 10mm handgun as a carry gun in Bear Country. These loads bring out the full potential of the 10MM but operate at standard pressures and as such, are safe to use in any standard 10MM pistol. The FBI adopted the 10mm then realized it was too powerful for normal officers. 357 Magnum Our trip was planned, but my buddy called off, so I went solo into opening day at south Sequoia National Park 1979. 357 Magnum load, it’s popped up three times on my radar this week and it’s something I want to do some shooting with. I always have a 9mm with me hiking but after running into a moose and a bear cub recently, I'm rethinking things. While the 10mm, is a good 'hunting-round' out to 50 yards or so, in it's 180 gr. VERY true, and that's handy. Ruger's GP100 Double-Action Centerfire Revolvers are renowned for dependability, accuracy and reliability. 357 Magnum can be relied upon for deep penetration and is more than capable of stopping a charging bear with good shot placement. The N99 10mm pistol is a weapon in Fallout: New Vegas. Other suggest a full-size all-steel 1911 platform in 10mm - but this weighs about what your. As the case it was originally designed around is longer than the 10mm, (1. 44magnum during ballistics test, however a handgun would not be my first choice for bear protection, especially grizzly. 40 S&W and the. Triple-locking cylinder provides positive alignment. We accept returns. 40 S&W, the 9×25mm Super Auto G and the 9×25mm Dillon, with the. The 10mm is a great service round, but you are not going to hose down a 500# grizz in cover w/ your Glock & expect to stop him. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing typ. I would use them for different purposes. It's great for competition. I have Been a Fan of the 10MM for almost 2 decades. 357 fired from a 4" barrel. My loads from DoubleTap are rated at 616 ft lbs of energy out of a G29. 10mm 19 30-30 Winchester 300 AAC Blackout-Whisper 7. 357 for the simple reason I can reach out a little farther with it accurately than the. Looking for a pack gun, pistol, carried in shoulder or chest holster, in Kodiak country, Alaska. The Texas DPS has no trouble "taming" felonious criminals behind the windshields of tractor trailer trucks with their. The 10mm originally used by the FBI was changed to 10mm lite because the. Lesson learned never keep food for bears in your camp site. 8” of weight and reduces muzzle flip and felt recoil. The 10mm auto cartridge with a height of 0. has plenty of punch for deer-sized game. 29 inches for the. Traditional western-style, hand-filling grip has long been acknowledged as one of the most comfortable and natural pointing of any grip style. I was interested in a 357 because of less recoil and cheaper ammo. All the rest were aware of my presence before I knew they were there. Definitely not suitable for grizzly/brown. The 10mm beats the 357 for me just because of the light rail and night sights. 357 6 shot revolver, or a 15 shot Glock 20 (10mm auto)? What about the same. with less HSM offers three different rounds including a bear. American shooters think the more rounds they throw, the better. It can be handloaded to near. 45 GWM was a powerful wildcat round designed for the LAR Grizzly pistol. The two power levels offered by most ammo manufacturers give the option of relatively soft-recoiling home defense rounds, or magnum revolver performance for hunting or defense from medium-sized carnivores like cougar or black bear. 357 Magnum is that it works well in high capacity pistols like Glocks, Sig Sauers, Heckler & Kochs and the like, where as the. 357 Pugnose. 357 and 5 inch 10mm. Having killed dozens of bear and guided hunters for dozens more, I have firsthand knowledge. 45 with 230g +P load would be a better choice. The N99 was known for its ability to survive in the harshest of conditions and did so in many tests, as the weapon was reliably able to be restored. stopping power. I don't think the. I decided to run a 10mm head to head with a. 357 v 10mm road again, because in factory guns, the. So a heavy 10mm would do as well. I carry a. My Father had a Colt Delta Elite and i loved it, So my first handgun purchase was a "can you guess" a Colt Delta Elite. With similar ballistic performances, I would stick with the. Better For Bear. With summer comes backpacking into the wilderness, camping trips, followed by archery season and the general rifle big game season. My first thought was, crap, all I have is this 10mm, this is not good. Good compromise load for self-defense in bear country. It can be handloaded to near. Complete 10mm Auto ammunition ballistics Chart. August 10, 2015. 357 is certainly good enough to protect mine. Even then, ONLY as a back-up to a shotgun loaded with sabot slugs or a rifle in a much different magnum caliber. Double Tap in their 200gr, gas checked, hard-cast bullets is a good choice in black bear country. 357 Magnum, though the 10mm uses heavier projectiles that range from about 135 grains to 230 grains (165 to 200 are most common) though lighter loadings are available. 357 are compared quite often, when the bullet weight is 200 grain (for instance) and a standard Glock 20 is compared to a 6”. 357 magnum with hollow points. It’s powerful enough to use against the bears found there, and as an added bonus, the. Have reloading set ups for both. 45ACP loaded with hot rounds. 45 and has a bullet weight that sheds speed more slowly. Until now, I have never had to shoot an unwounded bear to protect either myself or clients. 357 does offer a noticeable advantage in terms of penetrating power, which is something to consider if you're hunting big game. I wouldn't want to take it grizzly hunting as my primary weapon, but I would use it for black bear or deer. I decided to run a 10mm head to head with a. In the 9-to-40 comparison, we have a smaller, lighter bullet versus a slower. 10mm leaves you open for a wider range of handgun options. 357 mag revolvers. My loads from DoubleTap are rated at 616 ft lbs of energy out of a G29. But, hollow points would not have been the round of choice. That's why HSM's exclusive Bear Load has been a most popular seller since its introduction in 2011. If you want 15 rounds of deeply penetrating hard cast bear defense bullets, it can do that. Maybe a better comparison would be 10mm vs. Designed by the combined genius of Dornas and Dixon for the Bren Ten Auto Combat Pistol and at the behest of Col. I prefer a 4" 44 Mag S&W in bear country, but will admit there were times I carried a 1911, in griz country, in 45 ACP, with 230gr Ball, and later on the Buffalo Bore 230gr +P FP. 40 S&W, the 9×25mm Super Auto G and the 9×25mm Dillon, with the. 357 Magnum than a. Advertised as the world’s most powerful handgun cartridge, the. These are the absolute heaviest bullet that can be fired through 10mm pistols. The 10mm Auto (10×25mm, official C. Welcome to Grizzly Cartridge Never settling for second best, the result is a company whose bullets and cartridges will deliver exactly what you need every round, every time. 357 might have the power advantage over the other options. trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. If that means 9mm, then I doubt any bear would fancy a magful in the facial/cranial area. 45 for back up in black bear country?. I almost put this in the hunting section since many people who hunt consider the 10mm an option but there are also many people who choose a 10mm or 45 for "woods gun" for protection against bears. A bear is usually tougher than the sides of cars anyway. See individual spec sheets for model specific features. 38 Specials through it. 357 Magnum 180. You'll have to adjust the dies however they need to be for whichever it is you're reloading, regardless of whether they'll do 40 or 10mm. Leave nothing to chance when traveling through bear country. 40 S&W and the. Guns of Once Upon a. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing typ. 158gr @ 1413. Yes…you can get 357 Mag velocities using 155 grain 40 cal bullets…+ – 1,300 FPS…. No thanks! A full grown polar bear is enormous. From my experience. 357 are very close. 357 Magnum is that it works well in high capacity pistols like Glocks, Sig Sauers, Heckler & Kochs and the like, where as the. 357 at the time - must be good, right? Then I got a job which included performing necropsies on wild critters - including black and grizzly bears. 357 stoked with hardcast heavy for caliber bullets in the woods. But the semi auto in 10mm is a good choice for a general woods gun. In reality you are highly unlikely to have a bear problem. 357 penetration at 22 inches. Let's just love the 10mm for what it is, a really good idea. 357 mag in terms of performace, and. 38 Super was chosen by many lawmen for its ability to punch through automobile bodies - ie: the ones of its day which were made with STEEL. Additionally, I have been hanging around bear guides all my adult life and between us, we've seen over a thousand bears killed. 357 Sig is the opportunity for increased accuracy, the same extreme velocity, deep penetration the 10mm I have currently provides me with and all in a much SMALLER/comfortable/more concealable package. I've only ever seen 1 black bear before he saw me. 357 Magnum 180. it is according to what I may have to use it for. Usually they throw out that the 10mm 'approaches'. Have reloading set ups for both. The 10mm Auto is the most powerful of the mainstream (keyword there) semi-auto rounds, with power levels on par with or exceeding the. 44 magnum for bear defense? Scenario: Your are bowhunting in Montana. 10mm for Grizzly protection - page 2 - 10mm 10mm would be viable defense for Black bears and maybe medium browns but this thing is a beast. 357 Sig vs. Another slightly reduced 10mm load in the. As a teen I spent summers with my siblings at my dad's in Alaska, and there'd be reports of bear maulings quite often. Two new 10mm TRP™ Operator® models – one with a 5-inch barrel, and a longslide with a 6-inch barrel – deliver tactically proven engineering, greater terminal velocity and now more stopping power. VERY true, and that's handy. 357 are compared quite often, when the bullet weight is 200 grain (for instance) and a standard Glock 20 is compared to a 6". Springfield Armory’s most elite production 1911, now available in the potent 10mm cartridge. 357 Magnum load, it’s popped up three times on my radar this week and it’s something I want to do some shooting with. But, hollow points would not have been the round of choice. As a result, in the 10mm vs. It seems that the 10mm gets next to no respect. Going with 357 leaves you open for more rifle options. 357 and 5 inch 10mm. The Ruger SR1911 in 10mm Auto is bound to be popular with the “bigger is always better” crowd, and many are hopeful that with a company like Ruger getting into the ten-mil market, it will help ammunition manufacturers come down in price on this powerhouse self-defense cartridge. 44 magnum is even better if you prefer something bigger and a wheelgun. 357 Magnum and yield less recoil than the. , and does so in a service-sized semi-automatic pistol. 202, the SD of a 200 grain 10mm (. 357 mag or. However, the 10mm Auto is no slouch, and if you place your shots properly, it'll do the trick. 357 6 shot revolver, or a 15 shot Glock 20 (10mm auto)?. Buy at this store. com, heavy metal bullets can be used to reload, cast lead bullets are fun to shoot, shooting is fun to do many times, reloading saves money, reloading is more accurate than brand ammunition, buy cast lead bullets from heavy metal bullets, reload your idpa and ispc and uspsa reloads with heavy metal bullets, cast lead bullets make reloading. Another slightly reduced 10mm load in the. 44 Mag, in 300 gr. The 357’s range of useful bullet weights is 90 to 200 grains; and loaded to about 1500 fps, that 200 penetrates like there’s no tomorrow. The 10mm has more "felt recoil" than the. 357 Sig vs 10mm vs 5. I unfortunately purchased a MC 357 4 or 5 weeks before the announcement for the 10mm. You can use it for self-defense, and even for hunting deer, bear, etc. a mag full of 10MM?. It seems that the 10mm gets next to no respect. Usually they throw out that the 10mm 'approaches'. Power the 1076 has, dispensing energy comparable to a. 454 Casull in case I’m. This really is a test of my ability to shoot 357Magnum and 10mm of essentially the same power factor. A 40 Caliber Nightmare Is Caught On Tape. I decided to run a 10mm head to head with a. over penetration is not a concern with handguns and bears. Take a look at your budget. 40 S&W ammo in a bind, lots of people are hard core. 44 Magnum? Only in the great American wilderness, in parts where bears are common. In many ways, the story of the. 357 Magnum question is about to be answered once and for all. It appears, in short, the best 10mm load in the best 10mm handgun may "kill" a black bear -- eventually -- but it can't necessarily be counted on to "stop" one reliably. 45ACP, but is still manageable (for me). This is a discussion on 10mm vs 45 +P within the Handguns forums, part of the Gun Forum category; I keep hearing about the 10mm and its effectiveness as a hunting round. I have been guiding brown bear hunters and fishermen and bear photographers from our homestead within Becharof National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska for 33 years and have had numerous close encounters with bears. But the semi auto in 10mm is a good choice for a general woods gun. 19 After Show. Single-action vs Double-action. When compairing the 180 grain in both the 10mm and. 357 fired from a 4" barrel. If you’re looking for versatility and a budget-savvy round, the. But no one can fathom this, you want to rely on it more power to you. If you want a solid defensive pistol with moderate recoil and good terminal performance, it can do that too. In this case, I'd carry the most powerful round that you can shoot quickly & accurately. 357 bullet is 9. 45 face-off? Read and learn which of these calibers is the best in the business. 40 S&W or 9mm and the performance of larger calibers such as the. 357 Magnum than a. 44 mag in bear country (and I am thinking. 40auto, 10mm,. 357 magnum has a long track record of a mini-hand cannon for personal defense. XTP: 1180 fps, 550 ft-lbs. 5" barrel and 10 mm are 5" barrel. but on a serious note. 44 Magnum,. 357 Magnum than a. The 10mm penetration was around 16 inches. As a result, in the 10mm vs. From my experience. 357 Magnum is that it works well in high capacity pistols like Glocks, Sig Sauers, Heckler & Kochs and the like, where as the. 357 Magnum revolver for years as his bear gun. "Stopping" bears with handgun or rifle cartridges. it is according to what I may have to use it for. And with a heavier bullet, the. Towsley , Tyler Freel , and John B. As the case it was originally designed around is longer than the 10mm, (1. If that means 9mm, then I doubt any bear would fancy a magful in the facial/cranial area. You really cannot compare a 10mm to the other rounds, it is a very good hunting round and has taken everything up to Grizzly bears but comparing it to a. The Texas DPS has no trouble "taming" felonious criminals behind the windshields of tractor trailer trucks with their. 300 Remington Ultra Mag. 357 Magnum Our trip was planned, but my buddy called off, so I went solo into opening day at south Sequoia National Park 1979. Welcome to BulkAmmo. You can see the full results and details on the post at Lucky Gunner Labs. Having taken a black bear with a. 45 discussions, 10mm is not a clear winner. has plenty of punch for deer-sized game. the 10mm is some what over kill and 40 hot loads. Another guy in New Mexico failed to stop a black bearquickly enough with his 10mm, even with multiple hits. Developed primarily as a law enforcement pistol cartridge, the. 357 Sig will also solve it, and in a smaller package. Loaded with the venerable Barnes TAC-XP bullets, TAC-XPD ammunition is engineered and designed to deliver top performance when it is most critical: in life-threatening situations The TAC-XP's all-copper construction and very large, deep hollow-point cavity expand, penetrate and perform more consistently than any personal defense product on. 357 mag, I'd be hesitant to recommend a 10mm even for that. 45 has a bigger bullet that would open a larger wound channel. If you choose to carry a 10mm semi auto pistol going into big bear country as your primary side arm - you are bats. 45 is a great round for those up close and personal encounters but beyond 25 yards I struggle to keep the shots on a paper plate. Hochzeitsgeschenk. The lesson I learned here was a simple one. To your original question comparing the hard cast 10mm bullets to. A 10mm, even a hot one, is probably way too light for stopping a determined black bear charge. 357 Sig is the opportunity for increased accuracy, the same extreme velocity, deep penetration the 10mm I have currently provides me with and all in a much SMALLER/comfortable/more concealable package. 45 is a great round for those up close and personal encounters but beyond 25 yards I struggle to keep the shots on a paper plate. 5-16" of penetration again depending on the company you buy, and while great it penetrates more factor in recoil vs gun, vs the abuse the gun takes etc. Complete 10mm Auto ammunition ballistics Chart. 357 Magnum is that it works well in high capacity pistols like Glocks, Sig Sauers, Heckler & Kochs and the like, where as the. 357 Magnum and yield less recoil than the. over penetration is not a concern with handguns and bears. Yes…you can get 357 Mag velocities using 155 grain 40 cal bullets…+ – 1,300 FPS…. 357 ammo are easy to come by. Defense Against Bears with Pistols: 97% Success rate, 37 incidents by Caliber. How to Pick the Right Sidearm for Backup Bear Protection Two experts square off on their picks for the ideal bear defense handgun By Will Brantley , Bryce M. The facts simply bear us out on this one — some 357 Magnum cartridges are suitable for backwoods self-defense, and some are not. With similar ballistic performances, I would stick with the. 357 revolver does, so you lose the weight savings of the Glock. 0 inch barrel will fit any and all Bond Arms Derringers. Spring fishing season is upon us. 10mm vs 45 +P. cast lead bullets are affordable at heavymetalbullets. 357 SIG duplicates the external ballistics of the show-stopping. Always liked a 357 full house load for "low country" (no bears) bumming around. A 40 Caliber Nightmare Is Caught On Tape. 357SIG 01-31-2002, 02:20 PM I currently own a Glock 23, very nice gun, accurate, easy to operate, lightweight, but I have read a lot about the. 357 - my "bear" protection, SHTF, gun. Handgun Caliber Showdown Round 2:. With modern loads this isn't necessarily true. 357 and 41 mag, can't understand the logic of trying to stop a 200 plus pound mammal with a round you wouldn't use for deer. 357 SIG, the. All things considered, the 10mm Automatic is a really good all around hunting cartridge: it’s accurate, hard hitting, flat shooting, and has manageable recoil. He shouldn't have tried to shoot the spinal column through the front, go straight to the brain pan. 357 are compared quite often, when the bullet weight is 200 grain (for instance) and a standard Glock 20 is compared to a 6”. 45 face-off? Read and learn which of these calibers is the best in the business. 357 is stuck in the. The Ruger SR1911 in 10mm Auto is bound to be popular with the “bigger is always better” crowd, and many are hopeful that with a company like Ruger getting into the ten-mil market, it will help ammunition manufacturers come down in price on this powerhouse self-defense cartridge. just buy a redhawk and walk with an eased mind. Self Defense in the Forest. 357 Magnum is better because you can shoot. With summer comes backpacking into the wilderness, camping trips, followed by archery season and the general rifle big game season. 357 SIG, can push a slightly heavier 135-grain bullet at a whopping 1,600 feet per second out of a 4. In mark3smle test you can see the. The 10mm Auto ammo is a pistol size cartridge commonly used by the Special Weapon & Tactics Teams of the FBI and the FBI Hostage Rescue Team. Said it was easy hunting. I would use them for different purposes. 20 Best 10mm Handguns For Sale in 2019. Towsley , Tyler Freel , and John B. Like both the Bren Ten and the Model 1076, the Delta. 7x28mm! I hope you enjoy the video and thanks for watching!. With regard to this face off, the. Bear in mind that we all have different hand sizes and hand strengths. I was much. 10mm vs 45 +P. bear EXPERIENCE, especially from anyone who used a 10mm on a grizzly or brown and survived, and about terminal effects on the bear. 62X35mm 3 357 Magnum 3 357 Sig Sauer 2 380 Automatic. And I do not feel that it will ever replace the. 357 penetration at 22 inches. 357 magnum has a long track record of one-shot stops on attackers of all types. The 10mm Auto is a intriguing round in he handgun world. 19 After Show. It is plenty powerful for about anything short of Brown bears The 357 Mag is a rimmed case designed for use in revolvers. 357 Magnum 180. 10mm vs 357. Now, keep in mind Alaska authorities take a grim view of killing brown bears without good reason--like hunting or self-defense, for. 44 Magnum or other larger cartridge. 357 at the muzzle generates as much as 20% more energy than a typical. 357 Sig comparison after I discussed the 9 mm cartridge versus the newer. That was the semi auto answer to it anyway. For instance a 200gr 10mm at 1256 get you 700 ft/lbs vs. Luckily most manufacturers offer their own special lines of JSP ammo, and this can take care of that problem. So a heavy 10mm would do as well. Cold streams tumble out of the rockies not yet filled with sediments of major snowmelt and summer is mere weeks away. The selection of firearms chambered in 10mm is. Those that are successful in Alaska are those who are flexible, and allow the reality of life in Alaska to shape their dreams, vs. Hornady recommends this bullet for "medium game" (Class 2), which would presumably include wolf, cougar and possibly black bear, but not grizzly, brown and polar bear. But If a 357 is a gun that fits the need, the GP100 is a dandy. In reality you are highly unlikely to have a bear problem. It is generally assumed the. Soshort of the 10mm or. Other suggest a full-size all-steel 1911 platform in 10mm - but this weighs about what your. I think for bear, it would be. Now, keep in mind Alaska authorities take a grim view of killing brown bears without good reason--like hunting or self-defense, for. 44magnum during ballistics test, however a handgun would not be my first choice for bear protection, especially grizzly. Definitely not suitable for grizzly/brown. Underwood 200 gr. The 10mm penetration was around 16 inches. Penetration tests on a gel block measured 24 inches, which is about 10 inches more than a. The 10mm beats the 357 for me just because of the light rail and night sights. However, the majority of the market prefers the 9mm. 357 to a 10mm would be a decent replacement. 357 SIG ammo rounds. You can still find hunting, target shooting or defense ammo in JSP with unique features such as a boat tail or polymer tip. Read Comments. Kentucky Ballistics videos are for entertainment purposes only. 357 mag to. For a more accurate comparison, go to handloads. My first thought was, crap, all I have is this 10mm, this is not good. 40 S&W, the 9×25mm Super Auto G and the 9×25mm Dillon, with the. Garrett Cartridges - Products. If I'm using the handgun instead of the rifle it's likely to be when I can't see the bear coming from far away which may be at night. I guess what got me to thinking was that right now I carry a. This was due to the excessive recoil which many to-be, and in the field LEO who scored poorly. I’d say an 8-shot N frame S&W in 357 or a 1911 style 10mm with long slide. The 9mm vs. Started by john james , Mar 22 2015 If I were hunting with a handgun it would probably be a Glock 10MM for close range for the.